Two different tools for two different jobs
"Should we use AI or a rules-based flow" is the wrong question — most support queues need both, just for different questions. The useful question is which one handles which conversation.
When a rules-based flow wins
For anything predictable, compliance-sensitive, or extremely high-volume — order status, appointment confirmations, opt-outs — a scripted flow is faster, cheaper, and never improvises an answer it shouldn't. You know exactly what it will say before it says it.
When an AI agent wins
Open-ended questions that don't map to a fixed script — "does this work with my setup," "what's the difference between these two plans" — are where a knowledge-base-connected AI agent earns its keep, because writing a rule for every phrasing isn't realistic.
Running both in the same inbox
In practice, the two hand off to each other: a rules-based flow handles the routine 80%, and escalates to an AI agent — or a human — the moment a question falls outside its confidence. Neither one has to cover everything on its own.